The IMF or EMF??

We rise in glory as we sink in pride. This is what I have to say to the EU leaders and ECB officials, as they quickly dismiss any talks of an IMF rescue for Greece. The IMF seems to me the best way out for Greece with all its fiscal mess and politics involved in the matter. Let’s face it, that today no eurozone country is audacious or willing enough to get into this ‘delicate’ issue of sovereign default and debt assurance, specially after grinding through such terrible economic times. What Greece is looking right now is for some generous donor to grant an easy loan with low interest rates and in return it will promise to cut down its fiscal deficit by adopting real disciplinary measures.

Here are a few reasons in a nutshell as to why I feel Greece’s bailout is a ‘delicate’ issue:

ü      Any loan or bailout money provided to Greece would be along with a number of constraints attached to it. Nobody would be willing to give a ‘no-frills’ loan to Greece considering its past record of conceited accounting practices and inexperienced policy makers. It is obvious common sense that any entity would like to protect its investment and make sure it oversees its utilisation.

ü      Secondly, there is an inevitable political angle as well which needs to be looked into. There already massive protests across Greece by its unhappy citizens over the government’s resolute commitment to cut public spending and public sector pay freezes. Already unions have endured enough, and one feels that the tipping point is not far away. Thus, in such a heated political environment, having foreign country or interests dictate control and supervision over its policymaking will further add to the fire.

ü      Thirdly, all hopes of the Euro’s future are hinged on a quick, transparent and stable Greek recovery, as the fear of contagion spreading to Portugal, Italy and Spain is high. As a consequence, any hiccups in the bailout may cause sharp reactions from bond markets. Which leads to my argument that what is required is a patient and calibrated approach, but not many would be looking at long term scenario, except the IMF.

Who will take out the chequebook?

Setting aside the IMF as one major contender for this job, let us examine who are the possible contenders. First on the list is the EU, which cannot explicitly bail Greece out as per the treaty clause which governs its functioning. Second, would be unilateral loans form the rich and prosperous European states, which in its current circumstances narrow down to Germany. Germany is the real powerhouse of Europe, also being one of the main beneficiaries of the introduction of Euro currency. Thus, more than an obligation, the last thing Germans want is a euro collapse in a fragile recovery period of today.

But, the German public is outraged by the idea of bailing out the profligate Greeks with their hard earned savings. To me a German bailout looks less probable than a German supervision. This leaves us with only 2 remaining choices. One is a real institution with more than 60 years experience of handling such cases, none other than the IMF. The other is EMF, which is fictitious and is a yet to be started fund. And so one feels the idea of EMF is promoted purely on pride and less logic.

It drives me nuts to read how EU policy makers are so blindly hopeful on setting up the European Monetary Fund as it is currently named. The IMF is clearly a better alternative even though the setting up of EMF is great for future crises but not the present Greece concern at hand. In simple terms, on having met with an accident does a person go to a experienced and reputed hospital, or does one choose go to a new, inexperienced and a politically correct clinic. Of course one chooses the former over the later. Then why make a distinction here for Greece.

Greece certainly needs help, and IMF for me looks like the safest bet. Disillusioned European leaders and policymakers need to shun their pride and also look at another positive from it. An IMF rescue will set a good example for the rest of the eurozone nations. An EMF rescue even if possible will imply a ‘too big-to fail’ guarantee, which will make future defaults even more dangerous.